Which MacBook to get?

Live forum: http://forum.freeipodguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=78649

unknown uchiha

31-03-2009 18:27:11

I'm getting $2500 in Apple Gift Cards from the Reward Depot soon, so price is not an issue here. I'm torn between choosing two things

1. The 13.3" Unibody Macbook @ $1599 ($1499 with student discount)
2.4 GHz
4GB DDR3 RAM (+$90)
320GB Hard Drive (+$67)
NVIDIA GeForce 9400M
2 USB 2.0 ports
MiniDisplay Port

2. The 15.4" Unibody MacBook Pro @ $2499
2.66 GHz
4GB DDR3 RAM
320GB Hard Drive
NVIDIA GeForce 9400M + 9600M GT (512MB)
3 USB 2.0 ports
1 FireWire 800 port
1 ExpressCard/34 slot
MiniDisplay Port

I'm upgrading from a white MacBook here =P

I can't decide on whether or not I need the bigger, more powerful laptop (though it is justifiable). I have it for personal use, involving schoolwork and editing film. I think I want a Pro, but the biggest concern is the Pro being a bit "too big" to carry around (though I've seen it countless times at the Apple Store and wherever and have played around with it). I know for a fact that I plan on loading up Left 4 Dead when I get it (on Windows, of course!) =P

Actually I think I've just talked myself into sticking with the Pro, even though getting a regular 13.3" MacBook will leave me enough Apple credit to get the third-gen iPhone when it launches along with an iPod Classic for my car and AppleTV. lol.

tjwor

31-03-2009 21:28:17

I have a 15" MBP, and it really isn't a hassle to take to class. I wish I had the money to upgrade, mine is getting a little outdated and begining to slow a bit...

I would not be suited well with the 13" because I enjoy having enough space when working with iweb to access things from my desktop and not have to move windows around off of the screen...

theysayjump

31-03-2009 22:58:56

With my cards from Reward Depot I got the Macbook Pro with the slower CPU and smaller HDD, but upgraded to 4GB of ram. With the extra cash on the card I got a refurbished 160GB iPod and express shipping.

I also dual-boot with XP and it's a huge battery hog, around 130-200 compared to 5hrs+ on OS X.

JennyWren

01-04-2009 13:00:10

I have to say I love my MBP (about a year and a half old now) but it is pretty big and heavy to carry around. I ride my bike a lot though.

cubbieco

04-04-2009 21:20:35

If you are editing film then go with the mac book pro. The regular mac book doesn't have fire wire which many cameras use to transfer video.

Iloveipods2

05-04-2009 04:46:17

Don't get a mac. PC > Mac.

SkatingCrippled

05-04-2009 07:47:02

[quote2e47ebc724="Iloveipods2"]Don't get a mac. PC > Mac.[/quote2e47ebc724]

Well, I doubt they sell PCs at the Apple store. lol

Iloveipods2

05-04-2009 10:00:12

[quoted629eb29fa="SkatingCrippled"][quoted629eb29fa="Iloveipods2"]Don't get a mac. PC > Mac.[/quoted629eb29fa]

Well, I doubt they sell PCs at the Apple store. lol[/quoted629eb29fa]

No, but they do sell macs w/ windows, and they do sell that program so you can run PC programs on macs. So he should just buy a PC. D

tjwor

05-04-2009 13:09:47

[quote900aafcb7b="Iloveipods2"][quote900aafcb7b="SkatingCrippled"][quote900aafcb7b="Iloveipods2"]Don't get a mac. PC > Mac.[/quote900aafcb7b]

Well, I doubt they sell PCs at the Apple store. lol[/quote900aafcb7b]

No, but they do sell macs w/ windows, and they do sell that program so you can run PC programs on macs. So he should just buy a PC. D[/quote900aafcb7b]

I think that the point is that he has a gift card for the apple store, which means he can't buy a PC, he can buy the dual boot program...


BTW...

MAC>PC

akalic

05-04-2009 19:43:44

[quote4e1977325a="tjwor"][quote4e1977325a="Iloveipods2"][quote4e1977325a="SkatingCrippled"][quote4e1977325a="Iloveipods2"]Don't get a mac. PC > Mac.[/quote4e1977325a]

Well, I doubt they sell PCs at the Apple store. lol[/quote4e1977325a]

No, but they do sell macs w/ windows, and they do sell that program so you can run PC programs on macs. So he should just buy a PC. D[/quote4e1977325a]

I think that the point is that he has a gift card for the apple store, which means he can't buy a PC, he can buy the dual boot program...


BTW...

MAC>PC[/quote4e1977325a]

I prefer fast, cost efficient computers over environmentally friendly ones thank you roll

theysayjump

05-04-2009 19:43:58

I'm pretty sure that BootCamp is free when you buy a new Mac, I know it came with mine.

mistertomlinson

07-04-2009 14:08:22

I'm late to reply but figured I'd do it anyway.

BootCamp is indeed free and allows you to run Windows NATIVELY (everything is supported and runs exactly as a PC would) and it'll be in your Applications/Utilities folder... and I give another vote for the 15." I think it's the perfect compromise between size and portability. I've owned numerous 13"s, 15"s and 17"s (thank you freebies) and a 12" iBook and 13" didn't quite cut it for me.

As for Mac vs PC... don't you know you're paying for "cool?!" I don't know about you, but I personally like being cool. It helps me sleep at night. wink