Plagiarism Is this allowed??

Live forum: http://forum.freeipodguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=56422

gmario

11-03-2007 04:02:24

Theres a user on the forums thats new and he has copied my topic on the trading post word by word and has been posting it on all the other forums, are people allow to do this? I don't find these fair because it took me quite some time to come up with it and its not fair for this noob to come and copy what i wrote and start posting it as his!!!

Topics the member has posted on FiPG and other forums
http//forum.freeipodguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=56070
http//freelunchroom.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=3594
http//www.anything4free.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=87846

gmario topic

http//forum.freeipodguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=53183

moviemadnessman

11-03-2007 04:07:55

I'm sorry to say, while it might not seem fair, it doesn't really seem like it goes against any rules. You don't have a monopoly on the wording, so while it is maybe ethically wrong that they did that, I think that they are entitled to do it.

The only thing you can do is ask them to make their own wording, but I think that there is nothing you can really do. Sorry, man.

gmario

11-03-2007 04:09:51

Grr!!! Just seems so stupid they obviously not going to change it they copied mine for a reason!! cry

moviemadnessman

11-03-2007 04:13:10

[quote4b3d1fd466="gmario"]Grr!!! Just seems so stupid they obviously not going to change it they copied mine for a reason!! cry[/quote4b3d1fd466]
Well, think of it like this ... flattery is the greatest compliment.

Although, I find it odd that they have "Trade with a +30 TR trader", but they only have 25 TR...they should fix that, at the very least.

gmario

11-03-2007 04:17:16

Yea its just pure BS that i always seem to be the target one x

moviemadnessman

11-03-2007 04:22:28

[quotef205fbbc5b="gmario"]Yea its just pure BS that i always seem to be the target one x[/quotef205fbbc5b]
Can you blame them, though? In about 3 and a half months, you've become the 12 highest trader on FiPG. That shows that you are doing something right, so the obvious thing would be to assume that your wording is key ... and new people want to be just like you ...

Sorry they keep copying your stuff, though. While I think you've done an awesome job trading, I can tell you I haven't copied any of your posts in any form [except quoting it] )

gmario

11-03-2007 04:27:37

I guess your right it's just sad how people can be so desperate to go to those limits and copy something i taken my time to write, and it scares that if i was to publish something the same might happen x

moviemadnessman

11-03-2007 04:32:53

[quotedfa29d90b1="gmario"]I guess your right it's just sad how people can be so desperate to go to those limits and copy something i taken my time to write, and it scares that if i was to publish something the same might happen x[/quotedfa29d90b1]
Just like the person who originally wrote the Project Payday information, which was then stolen and passed off as other people's work and they made a ton of money on it. Just to name one example ...

But yeah, I know what you mean. It would be hard not to feel pissed that you spend time typing something up and then some new person comes along and literally just does a copy/paste job.

gmario

11-03-2007 04:40:28

[quoted7b003e451="moviemadnessman"][quoted7b003e451="gmario"]I guess your right it's just sad how people can be so desperate to go to those limits and copy something i taken my time to write, and it scares that if i was to publish something the same might happen x[/quoted7b003e451]
Just like the person who originally wrote the Project Payday information, which was then stolen and passed off as other people's work and they made a ton of money on it. Just to name one example ...

But yeah, I know what you mean. It would be hard not to feel pissed that you spend time typing something up and then some new person comes along and literally just does a copy/paste job.[/quoted7b003e451]

Yea i read about that too and got freaked out even more since i get members from project payday asking me for help all the time shock so i know the stuff i write is at jeopardy if the wrong person gets a hold of it luckily it was just my trading topic this time (

Jams44

11-03-2007 07:40:52

[quote2126c95155="moviemadnessman"]
Well, think of it like this ... [b2126c95155]flattery[/b2126c95155] is the greatest compliment.

Although, I find it odd that they have "Trade with a +30 TR trader", but they only have 25 TR...they should fix that, at the very least.[/quote2126c95155]

you mean imitation is the greatest compliment

moviemadnessman

11-03-2007 10:49:23

[quote8125d23ce8="Jams44"][quote8125d23ce8="moviemadnessman"]
Well, think of it like this ... [b8125d23ce8]flattery[/b8125d23ce8] is the greatest compliment.

Although, I find it odd that they have "Trade with a +30 TR trader", but they only have 25 TR...they should fix that, at the very least.[/quote8125d23ce8]

you mean imitation is the greatest compliment[/quote8125d23ce8]
oops ... yes. I wrote it at like 330 in the morning (430 after the switch), so I wasn't thinking clearly. Yes, imitation is the greatest compliment...

gmario

11-03-2007 10:53:18

So i guess i got a lot of imitators x

FreeOffersNow

11-03-2007 10:54:30

[quote5cd2ebaba9="Jams44"][quote5cd2ebaba9="moviemadnessman"]
Well, think of it like this ... [b5cd2ebaba9]flattery[/b5cd2ebaba9] is the greatest compliment.

Although, I find it odd that they have "Trade with a +30 TR trader", but they only have 25 TR...they should fix that, at the very least.[/quote5cd2ebaba9]

you mean imitation is the greatest compliment[/quote5cd2ebaba9]

you mean "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery" )

moviemadnessman

11-03-2007 10:55:44

YES! There it is! ... I knew the exact wording would come around. +Karma to you ... mystery solved.

ew1075

11-03-2007 11:13:09

I wouldn't condone direct copying, but the guy is obviously trying to duplicate the success that you have had. Can't say that I blame him.

condra

11-03-2007 11:20:52

[quote940aad13eb="ew1075"]I wouldn't condone direct copying, but the guy is obviously trying to duplicate the success that you have had. Can't say that I blame him.[/quote940aad13eb]

i think he should get some imagination of his own...

comme on, that,s lame, copying without even saying a ''thanks'' or acknowledging that he took it from someone

roll

KeithA

11-03-2007 11:24:50

Since gmario has taken to threadcrapping in the guy's thread in the Trading Post, I'd say this thread is a little unnecessary now.

gmario, your TR and the way you conduct trades are what will ultimately keep you ahead of the game. Focus on those instead of polluting the forum and others' threads with petty complaints.