Timbaland Song "Do It" Was Stolen!

Live forum: http://forum.freeipodguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=53266

ffactoryxx

04-02-2007 22:15:47

Not exactly new news, but I'm sure it's news to some of you. Timbaland, the guy who made that single with Nelly Furturdo, stole a song from the 8-bit demo scene to make his song "Do It".

DIGG It
http//digg.com/music/Timbaland_ripped_off_a_track_from_my_buddy

Analytical Video Comparison
http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4KX7SkDe4Q

Another Great Listen of the ringtone. Same shit
http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=wV2fTEeP6GM

Download the Original MOD
(this is what Timbaland ripped off) USE VLC TO LISTEN TO MOD
http//www.file-wire.net/?pdl=mt4RrhlE0HhT


The original artist of the song is a Finnish chiptune guy called Janne Suni. He has not made a dime off this, meanwhile Timbaland is raking in millions. I love chip music, but Timbaland basically based his whole song on the exact melody. It's not a "sample", it's a direct cut-n-paste.

It's no secret that pop musicians have little or no true talent, but this is really pissing me off...

The RIAA protects artists from getting their music stolen but its ok for their artists to steal from users. Fuck them.

x323smostwantedx

04-02-2007 22:26:57

This is done all the time, sampling and stuff

hehehhehe

04-02-2007 22:45:35

[quotee1b8a8d324="x323smostwantedx"]This is done all the time, sampling and stuff[/quotee1b8a8d324]
Yeah but usually they pay and credit the artists they take things from.

findme

04-02-2007 23:28:35

[quotec37aebe8f0="x323smostwantedx"]This is done all the time, sampling and stuff[/quotec37aebe8f0]

come on now... it doesn't make any sense for others to deny others to use your beat when they can make a good song out of it. do u see the Finnish guy complaining? if he was a true artist he would be proud that his beat helped someone else out.

what is the world coming to.... people cant use a beat to have on his music.... sad!

the main question is ... did the guy who made the beat sue?

x323smostwantedx

04-02-2007 23:50:43

I didnt read if he denied it or not but yeah, he shouldve gaven him credit

Dave82

05-02-2007 01:04:01

[quote32c1f7ab69="findme"][quote32c1f7ab69="x323smostwantedx"]This is done all the time, sampling and stuff[/quote32c1f7ab69]

come on now... it doesn't make any sense for others to deny others to use your beat when they can make a good song out of it. do u see the Finnish guy complaining? if he was a true artist he would be proud that his beat helped someone else out.

what is the world coming to.... people cant use a beat to have on his music.... sad!

the main question is ... did the guy who made the beat sue?[/quote32c1f7ab69]

I sure fucking hope he does sue!!
It is not about being "proud that his beat helped someone else out." Hey, let me [b32c1f7ab69]steal[/b32c1f7ab69] your wallet. You should be proud that your money helps pay my tuition!

Dude ripped off someone else's hard work and passed it off as his own. Fucker. I hate it when they do this. You need to get permission and give credit. Period. Didnt "Dr" Dre lose a court battle for this?


what is the world coming to.... people cant make a beat to have on their own music.... sad!

mpj31

05-02-2007 01:51:21

Thats like saying kanye west's golddigger song stole a beat off a 70's song....

Nothing new. Where the hell do you think Timbalands going to give credit? In the song?

[if8513ed1f6]"Yo wattup this is DJ Timbaland in the building all credits to this beat go out to some random French dude."[/if8513ed1f6]

Please

ffactoryxx

05-02-2007 07:06:22

But he stole the whole song!

A big point is the RIAA. They defend stealing music from artists and sue adults and children alike yet could care less when one of their artists steals from an ordinary person

Nimh

05-02-2007 10:11:50

[quote19fe29ea36="mpj31"]Thats like saying kanye west's golddigger song stole a beat off a 70's song....

Nothing new. Where the hell do you think Timbalands going to give credit? In the song?

[i19fe29ea36]"Yo wattup this is DJ Timbaland in the building all credits to this beat go out to some random French dude."[/i19fe29ea36]

Please[/quote19fe29ea36]

No, you fucking idiot. He would give credit in the royalty check he owes that guy.

CollidgeGraduit

05-02-2007 10:13:13

[quote59b72df851="Nimh"][quote59b72df851="mpj31"]Thats like saying kanye west's golddigger song stole a beat off a 70's song....

Nothing new. Where the hell do you think Timbalands going to give credit? In the song?

[i59b72df851]"Yo wattup this is DJ Timbaland in the building all credits to this beat go out to some random French dude."[/i59b72df851]

Please[/quote59b72df851]

No, you fucking idiot. He would give credit in the royalty check he owes that guy.[/quote59b72df851]

Or somewhere in the CD jacket possibly.. but I agree, obviously he wouldn't do it in the song.

Dave82

05-02-2007 10:43:48

[quote6f91580b66="CollidgeGraduit"][quote6f91580b66="Nimh"][quote6f91580b66="mpj31"]Thats like saying kanye west's golddigger song stole a beat off a 70's song....

Nothing new. Where the hell do you think Timbalands going to give credit? In the song?

[i6f91580b66]"Yo wattup this is DJ Timbaland in the building all credits to this beat go out to some random French dude."[/i6f91580b66]

Please[/quote6f91580b66]

No, you fucking idiot.[b6f91580b66] He would give credit in the royalty check he owes that guy[/b6f91580b66].[/quote6f91580b66]

[b6f91580b66]Or somewhere in the CD jacket possibly.[/b6f91580b66]. but I agree, obviously he wouldn't do it in the song.[/quote6f91580b66]

exactly.

samz465

05-02-2007 13:08:28

[quotebba862ae80="mpj31"]Thats like saying kanye west's golddigger song stole a beat off a 70's song....

Nothing new. Where the hell do you think Timbalands going to give credit? In the song?

[ibba862ae80]"Yo wattup this is DJ Timbaland in the building all credits to this beat go out to some random French dude."[/ibba862ae80]

Please[/quotebba862ae80]

lolol.

Veek

05-02-2007 15:49:15

[quote5798b924c1="Nimh"][quote5798b924c1="mpj31"]Thats like saying kanye west's golddigger song stole a beat off a 70's song....

Nothing new. Where the hell do you think Timbalands going to give credit? In the song?

[i5798b924c1]"Yo wattup this is DJ Timbaland in the building all credits to this beat go out to some random French dude."[/i5798b924c1]

Please[/quote5798b924c1]

No, you fucking idiot. He would give credit in the royalty check he owes that guy.[/quote5798b924c1]

Aw, look at you being all worked up. How cute.

mpj31

05-02-2007 16:53:27

Royalty check?

Are you all saying you are stalkers and know who Timbaland sends money to and who he rips off of?

For all you know this [i123465541c]Finnish[/i123465541c] dude could be swimming in cash because he provided a sample for a popular American Pop Star.

Most likely though hes gaining publicity and for some no name [i123465541c]Finnish[/i123465541c] Dude, thats enough I'd say. Timbaland probably found the song on http//www.freesamplesrus.com. All I gotta say is stop making assumptions.

Find me an official news report that Timbaland officially jacked from this dude and is being sued, then I will apologize for being wrong.

Timbaland is probably top 5 producer in the game right now, I think anyone would be honored to have their song on his beat.

EatChex89

05-02-2007 16:54:09

He was Finnish, not French.

mpj31

05-02-2007 17:11:29

http//xxlmag.com/online/?p=6979

Interesting read. Also don't get me wrong. If the Finnish guy isnt getting paid, he should. Timbaland shouldn't have much problem paying that off, but if he refuses it is pretty dick.

Nimh

05-02-2007 21:41:17

[quotec252a26866="mpj31"]Royalty check?

Are you all saying you are stalkers and know who Timbaland sends money to and who he rips off of?

For all you know this [ic252a26866]Finnish[/ic252a26866] dude could be swimming in cash because he provided a sample for a popular American Pop Star.

Most likely though hes gaining publicity and for some no name [ic252a26866]Finnish[/ic252a26866] Dude, thats enough I'd say. Timbaland probably found the song on http//www.freesamplesrus.com. All I gotta say is stop making assumptions.

Find me an official news report that Timbaland officially jacked from this dude and is being sued, then I will apologize for being wrong.

Timbaland is probably top 5 producer in the game right now, I think anyone would be honored to have their song on his beat.[/quotec252a26866]

Well, according to both the Digg article and the video comparison, it says he has not been paid, and they are looking for a lawyer to sue (although he'll never win, unless has a lot of time, and a lot of money).

As for your link, while if it was some hard-to-track down artist, I could understand, but it seems to me once the artist finds out and contacts you, you should pay the man.

And Veek, the only reason I get so annoyed about shit like this is because I know as a musician myself, if anyone jacked any of my work and made money without me getting anything (publicity, a check, etc.), I'd be pissed. I'm sure you'd be pissed too.

Veek

05-02-2007 21:55:55

Probably so, but I wouldn't go calling people fucking idiots.

mpj31

09-02-2007 16:21:21

http//forums.sohh.com/showthread.php?t=813498

Timbaland responds, its from street fighter.