TR denied? Everything was legit... :( :( :(

I have a question about how it's decided to give people a +1 on their trade record or not. I recently completed a trade with Shadow300z, everything went smoothly, actually the easiest and most painless trade I've done so far. He went green for me first, then a few days later I went green for him. Unlike all of my other trades so far, I felt good about this one because there were no hang-ups or snags, and I was excited to actually be making progress on this. Finally, a trade where everything just clicks! Yeah! D So we PMed each other saying thanks for the trade, let's get our TRs updated and all that. Well you can imagine my surprise when I see that both of our TRs have been denied. shock My question is this if me and another person do [if8bc93cb4a]everything[/if8bc93cb4a] 100% correctly for a trade and get denied a TR, is it going to be impossible for me to ever increase my TR? Am I stuck in newbie-land forever, doomed to have to go first for people and keep getting scammed?

If other trades had gone as smoothly as this one I wouldn't mind so much, but to be stopped short after trying so hard to get multiple trades completed with no success, and to finally get this one done and [if8bc93cb4a]still[/if8bc93cb4a] be denied, it kind of takes away my hope for ever completing this, ya know? Kinda makes me think it would be easier to actually go out and buy the product than to put this much effort into making futile attempts on here. So if someone could please explain how you decide to give people TRs on here I would appreciate it so I can actually get a +1 TR for my other trades in the future. Thank you.

cause both of you were under 2TR at the time of the trade read the trade rules

I've been at 2TR ever since the trade began, and Shadow300z is currently at 2TR, though I'm not sure if he was when the trade began. However, from what I understand that would be a moot point anyway, when you consider this rule from the Rules for Trading Forum[=http//forum.freeipodguide.com/viewtopic.php?t=12651]Rules for Trading Forum

"If you have...
2+ TR you can always nominate another user once you complete a trade."

ask FON about it he denied the trade

[quote530ccbb54b="Stroid"]ask FON about it he denied the trade[/quote530ccbb54b]
he means freeoffersnow if you didnt catch that...
and as long as one of you was +2 when you requested tr it shouldn't matter if the other wasn't

Both users were < 2 TR at the time TR credit was requested. TR credit denied, topic locked.